Within the last few decades, our attitudes towards the poorest, or perhaps those who struggle most in our society, have seemingly changed marginally. Middle class citizens complain that while they toil at the office for hours on end trying to make a living, people who choose not to work are dawdling in the streets, begging for food or money, and spending federal tax dollars making trips to the emergency room to get necessary medical care because they don't have insurance. Upon encountering one another in person, the homeless are regarded by citizens (putting the government aside) in a hasty, indifferent, and disgusted manner. In The Pigeon by Patrick Süskind, protagonist Jonathan describes the envy he felt for a neighborhood homeless man in France who would use the money he'd collected from passersby each day to buy wine, bread, and sardines; every evening, he'd have himself a brilliant feast before curling up on his sheet of cardboard for a post-dinner nap.
Even with the explosion of popularity in rap music, a decent amount of which alludes to the struggles of ghetto America and the country's less privileged and more troubled youth, middle aged adults have still struggled to even sympathize with such groups of people. In The Pigeon, it took the homeless man's urination of a brown liquid nearby a row of cars in a parking lot for Jonathan to empathize with the scrutiny under which the man had to commit business that should have been private, and feel bad for his poor health. Not many suburb-dwellers in the US have this perspective, or would divert much attention from their busy lives to take steps to care for an underprivileged homeless person encountered in the city.
I'm reminded of Elvis' song "In the Ghetto" which depicts the sad life of a young man born into a ghetto--he begins to "roam the streets at night" once he becomes hungry, and reverts to theft and violence to get food and clothing. One verse reads,
"Oh people don't you understand
The child needs a helping hand
He'll grow to be an angry young man someday
Take a look at you and me
Are we too blind to see?
Do we simply turn our ears and look the other way?"
These lines speak to a valuable conjecture about our indifference to the struggles of the underprivileged classes--perhaps our ignorance stems from the fear of accepting the graveness of their situation; we have an underlying fear, or nightmare, of what would happen if all of our possessions were stripped from us, and we were demoted to such a standard of living. We then comfort ourselves with "I'd never let it happen to me," and then we question why they let their lives slip away, or do little to revamp them. We begin "us and them" thinking, forgetting what is in front of us is a human being. And in poor neighborhoods, where gang violence often escalates, we find it difficult to compare ourselves to them.
On the news for a time, there were briefs every night about youth that had been killed by virtue of gang warfare--sometimes innocent passersby caught in crossfire--and perhaps from this we have accepted that turbulence as their lifestyle, and disrespected the fact that they value their lives lowly enough to assimilate into drug circles, or gangs. We do not empathize with the tears we see the mothers cry because we would never let our children mingle in such an environment, or be put in such danger. However, we do not realize the reality of their situation: in such portions of society, it's "kill or be killed"; if one does not make themselves a 'bully' they'll be the next 'victim.' Reputations are important, getting a lot of people following you is critical, especially if you land in trouble. One would also be surprised by the degree to which people involved in such practices do it for money or goods or protection for their family. And even a gang their are strong relationships; one member would throw themselves into a violent conflict to protect another.
To balance, par say, our "alienation" of these classes of people, the government/media of our country as an institution is providing a means for empathy for them. Where reputation matters, one cannot pose themselves as weak or vulnerable, hence there is little exchange of emotions, and a lack of the empathy that would enable people to work towards healing. Expressed emotions are mainly restricted to anger, of a very defensive nature, that boils at the tip of weakness. Fear of defeat, for example, can spur aggression; in a National Geographic television episode about Louisville Prison in Ohio, one of the inmates remarked, "if anybody messes with me let them know I'm going to **** them up." However, music, specifically rap, can facilitate empathy between people. A popular rap song a few years ago by Maino called "All the Above," depicts how the artist went from being a nobody on the streets, going through the same struggles his intended audience does, to being a rich musical artist. One verse reads,
"Really what do you see
When you looking at me?
See me come up from nothing,
To me living my dreams.
I done been to the bottom,
I done suffered a lot,
I deserve to be rich,
Headed straight to the top."
What is important about lyrics like this, and similar songs, is that the message of triumph, success, and victory over a system previously 'set in stone,' is not only embraced by the audience it is seemingly meant for. Through being applicable to a wide variety of people, the lyrics not only empathize with the current graveness of struggling peoples' situation but also allow middle and upper class citizens to empathize with the struggles of the less privileged, and in doing so see the value of their lives. It is the young people who listen to this music that truly ignite the dialectic between empathy and alienation of the lower classes. Not all of them, to be sure, but many.
Many people also claim that rap music is detrimental to society because the lyrics can sometimes be so defensive and aggressive that it is dangerous for one to associate with them-- not only because of what kinds of actions they could inspire, but because of their negative impact on one's psychological health (seeing oneself as invincible, destroying everything in one's path to get something, etc.). But, when the artist and the audience member are not affiliated by means of gang or circle, shared anger can be a means of empathy, as much as it can negatively affect behavior. In popular rapper Eminem's "Recovery" album, his song "Not Afraid" features this catchy chorus,
"We'll walk this road together, through the storm
Whatever weather, cold or warm
Just let you know that, you're not alone
Holla if you feel that you've been down the same road."
Here we see an attempt to relate to the audience member, and distinguish himself from other rappers in the sense that he truly understands what people are struggling through. This does have some verity because of his made-public battle with drugs. On an emotional level, it's important to note how he comforts the audience member, though a seemingly aggressive fellow, with "you're not alone" and "holla if you FEEL you've been down the same road." This is interesting, considering that Eminem upturned his role in rapping through this song.
I don't know how popular it was among people who had been listening to his other music, however, I think it wouldn't be bad for them to continue to idolize him, for this song balances softer understanding (as we see in the chorus) with more aggressive, triumphant, anti-institutional lyrics. Many struggling people aren't exposed to any soft empathy, partially because showing weakness in those parts makes one vulnerable to scrutiny or attack, and therapists aren't always available (though new programs are being launched now to counsel troubled youth). Guantanamo Bay, for example, has shown us what a lack of counseling can lead to--due to poor treatment, the prisoners that leave often do with far more anger and anti-American sentiment than when they arrived. One is now in fact a potent Al-Quida leader.
In terms of how empathy and alienation of lower classes function as a dialectic--it happens on different levels. In terms of citizens, if we shift too far towards empathy with the struggling people, we begin to think we are of similar nature, then get nitpicky when cultural, behavioral, or psychological differences arise, and are again overcome with the importance of those differences, and revert to attitudes of indifference, or alienation. Also, political empathy towards those who struggle makes them less likely to try and escape their condition, or rise out of their horrid situation. However, if the government 'ignores' the lower classes, it is marked an inevitable shortfall of capitalism, and they don't want that. Hence, it's evident that neither empathy nor alienation exists in absolute, however, in being opposing forces they hold the dynamic of our society together. At points, empathy is greater than alienation, and at points vice-versa, because of a variety of factors.